kamion's Journal

and the award goes to......
" I am not sure we should do this."

" Why not, Potter, that judge looks like a very wise man to me."

" But would it not be unsupportive to JKR."

" What has wise judgement to do with supportiveness?"

" Well don't we own it to Jo, she gave our world shape."

" She gave you a cupboard under the stair the first 11 years of your life."

" You just say that because she doesn't like you. "

" As if I care, as long as you like me enough to love me."

" It's more the other way around,
loving you doesn't always mean liking you.
Maybe we should tell her."

" Are you nutters? It would be in the Daily Prophet
within the hour and everybody will
start calling me Potter's Pet on the Internet.
I did not make it to Chief-Healer of St.Mungo
because I am so likable, but because I am the best
and certainly because I jumped a bangwagon.

" She said we never be friends."

" Which prooves she isn't always right."

I have a question that cropped up reading the court transscripts:
Harry Potter got protection against the Avada Kedavra curse
thanks to the sacrifies his mother made.
This protection residented in his blood, but the protection would be lifted as soon as he became of age at 17.

now Rowling says this:
The key point is that Voldemort is keeping alive in
7 his own body the sacrifice that Harry's mother made for him
8 17 -- 16 years previously
( (212) 805-0300 pg 149 84EVWAR5 )
Now this is the same magic that stopped working for Harry when becoming a man, but is still working in Voldemort ( thanks to " blood of an enemy, forfully taken")?
I don't understand how the same magic can stop working in one body but stiil active in the other.
JKR makes a big issue over not understanding the key point of her novel, but to me it starts to look like a key plot hole.
From the first reading that whole surviving issue did not ring right to me.

FRom HBP on it is explained that Voldemort cannot die because of the Horcruxes, which it the motic of the external soul. Now in a New York courtroom is reveiled that Lilly's sacrifice was effectively also a Horcrux?